Ted and Unregulated (IUU) longline fishing fleets were operating from the

Ted and Unregulated (IUU) longline fishing fleets were operating from the mid-1990s until the mid-2000s [24,28]. Therefore the increase in the population of wandering albatrosses at Possession Island, and at other breeding sites in the southern Indian Ocean, remains paradoxical [30,31]. Our aim was to test the hypothesis that hidden ML240 web heterogeneity in susceptibility to accidental capture (and mortality) by longlines may partly explain this paradox. Based on the observation that within a population of a given seabird species some individuals appear to be more attracted to fishing vessels than others [32], including albatrosses [33,34], we hypothesize that this held for our study population of albatrosses, and can account for the paradoxical population trend. The population is assumed to be heterogeneous, with two types of individuals that reflect behavioral syndromes (animal personalities): those strongly attracted by fishing vessels and therefore susceptible to capture and mortality by longlines; and those less attracted by fishing vessels and therefore less susceptible to capture. However, neither the risk-taking or risk-avoiding behaviors can be measured because risk-taking individuals are likely to have been removed and no longer available in the population to measure these CBIC2 solubility traits. From this hypothesis we make the following predictions.PredictionIf heterogeneity to attraction and susceptibility to capture and accidental mortality by longlines is present in the study population, models explicitly accounting for heterogeneity in survival with two categories of individuals should better predict the survival data than models with only one category of individuals. We thus predict selection of models including two categories of individuals, with one category characterized by a lower survival than the other.PredictionIf prediction 1 is verified, and given the assumed higher susceptibility of attracted individuals to mortality in longline fisheries and the observed increase in fishing effort through time, we expect the proportion of the category of individuals with the lowest survival to decline and the proportion of individuals of the other category to increase through time. Eventually, once all the individuals of the category with the lowest survival are removed from the population, the proportion of individuals of the other category would remain relatively stable, and if all individuals from the category with the lowest survival are removed then those left would only be individuals from the other category. In addition, the decrease in the proportion of individuals from the category with the lowest survival should coincide with the increase in fishing effort in the foraging area.Figure 1. Changes in the proportion of newly encountered individuals (successful breeders) from category 1 in the population of wandering albatrosses from Possession Island between 1960 and 2010. Parameter estimates are from Model 2. Errors bars are 95 confidence intervals. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0060353.gMaterials and Methods Ethics StatementResearch conducted was approved by the ethic committee of Institut Paul Emile Victor (IPEV) and by the Comite de ?l’Environnement Polaire.PLOS ONE | www.plosone.orgDifferential Susceptibility to BycatchTable 1. Modeling the effect of heterogeneity and time on survival and initial proportions of two categories newly encountered individuals wandering albatross at Possession Island.Model ph:s sh (1) ph:s sh (2) (3) ph:s s(4)Hypo.Ted and Unregulated (IUU) longline fishing fleets were operating from the mid-1990s until the mid-2000s [24,28]. Therefore the increase in the population of wandering albatrosses at Possession Island, and at other breeding sites in the southern Indian Ocean, remains paradoxical [30,31]. Our aim was to test the hypothesis that hidden heterogeneity in susceptibility to accidental capture (and mortality) by longlines may partly explain this paradox. Based on the observation that within a population of a given seabird species some individuals appear to be more attracted to fishing vessels than others [32], including albatrosses [33,34], we hypothesize that this held for our study population of albatrosses, and can account for the paradoxical population trend. The population is assumed to be heterogeneous, with two types of individuals that reflect behavioral syndromes (animal personalities): those strongly attracted by fishing vessels and therefore susceptible to capture and mortality by longlines; and those less attracted by fishing vessels and therefore less susceptible to capture. However, neither the risk-taking or risk-avoiding behaviors can be measured because risk-taking individuals are likely to have been removed and no longer available in the population to measure these traits. From this hypothesis we make the following predictions.PredictionIf heterogeneity to attraction and susceptibility to capture and accidental mortality by longlines is present in the study population, models explicitly accounting for heterogeneity in survival with two categories of individuals should better predict the survival data than models with only one category of individuals. We thus predict selection of models including two categories of individuals, with one category characterized by a lower survival than the other.PredictionIf prediction 1 is verified, and given the assumed higher susceptibility of attracted individuals to mortality in longline fisheries and the observed increase in fishing effort through time, we expect the proportion of the category of individuals with the lowest survival to decline and the proportion of individuals of the other category to increase through time. Eventually, once all the individuals of the category with the lowest survival are removed from the population, the proportion of individuals of the other category would remain relatively stable, and if all individuals from the category with the lowest survival are removed then those left would only be individuals from the other category. In addition, the decrease in the proportion of individuals from the category with the lowest survival should coincide with the increase in fishing effort in the foraging area.Figure 1. Changes in the proportion of newly encountered individuals (successful breeders) from category 1 in the population of wandering albatrosses from Possession Island between 1960 and 2010. Parameter estimates are from Model 2. Errors bars are 95 confidence intervals. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0060353.gMaterials and Methods Ethics StatementResearch conducted was approved by the ethic committee of Institut Paul Emile Victor (IPEV) and by the Comite de ?l’Environnement Polaire.PLOS ONE | www.plosone.orgDifferential Susceptibility to BycatchTable 1. Modeling the effect of heterogeneity and time on survival and initial proportions of two categories newly encountered individuals wandering albatross at Possession Island.Model ph:s sh (1) ph:s sh (2) (3) ph:s s(4)Hypo.